Why Informal Rulemaking is Important for Effective Governance

Informal Rulemaking: An Essential Ingredient for Effective Governance

What do you think of when you hear the word “governance”? The word conjures up images of rules, regulations, and red tape that govern society. But the truth is, governance is much more than that. Effective governance is the process of managing and implementing policies and regulations that are in the best interests of society. And at the heart of effective governance is a process known as informal rulemaking.

Informal rulemaking, also known as notice-and-comment rulemaking, is a process by which federal agencies propose, review, and finalize rules. The process is “informal” because it allows for public input and feedback, which in turn helps to shape the final rule. This process is critical to ensuring that federal agencies are transparent, accountable, and responsive to the needs of the communities they serve.

The Importance of Citizen Participation

One of the main benefits of informal rulemaking is that it encourages citizen participation. Through public comments, citizens have the opportunity to voice their concerns and provide valuable feedback to the agencies shaping the rules that govern their lives. This feedback is essential to ensuring that rules are not only effective but also reflective of the needs and concerns of the community.

For example, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) routinely solicits public feedback on proposed rules related to air and water quality. For example, in 2021, the EPA proposed new rules related to the regulation of lead in drinking water. During the informal rulemaking process, interested citizens had the opportunity to provide feedback and suggest changes to the proposed rules. This input helped shape the final rule, which was ultimately designed to ensure that lead levels in drinking water remain below the federally mandated safe level.

The Role of Expertise and Stakeholder Input

Another key benefit of informal rulemaking is that it allows for the solicitation of expert input. Federal agencies often turn to stakeholder groups, including industry representatives, advocacy organizations, and academic researchers, to provide expert opinions on proposed rules. This input is essential to ensuring that rules are based on sound science and are designed to achieve the intended outcomes.

For example, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) regularly consults with physicians and other healthcare providers when designing rules related to Medicare reimbursement. These experts provide insight into how proposed rules will impact their ability to provide care to their patients, which in turn helps to shape the final rule.

The Importance of Transparency and Accountability

Finally, informal rulemaking is essential to ensuring that federal agencies are transparent and accountable. By soliciting public comments and expert input, agencies are more likely to be responsive to the needs of the community. This transparency and accountability are critical to ensuring that the government is acting in the best interests of the people it serves.

For example, in 2018, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) proposed a repeal of net neutrality rules. Public outcry was significant, and the agency was inundated with comments opposing the repeal. Ultimately, the FCC voted to repeal the rules, but the transparency of the rulemaking process allowed for broad public debate and scrutiny of the decision.

Conclusion

In conclusion, informal rulemaking is a critical ingredient in effective governance. By soliciting public comments and expert input and providing transparency and accountability, federal agencies are more likely to design and implement rules that meet the needs and concerns of the communities they serve. Without this process, regulations could be crafted in a vacuum, without input from those most affected by them. While informal rulemaking may be seen by some as a cumbersome process, it is ultimately essential to ensure that government regulations are designed with the best interests of the people in mind.

Speech tips:

Please note that any statements involving politics will not be approved.